Cultural Appropriation in Marketing (Advertising & Marketing Law - concept 35)

 

Cultural Appropriation in Marketing 

Cultural appropriation in marketing occurs when a company uses elements of a culture—such as symbols, clothing, music, rituals, or language—without permission, respect, or understanding, often for commercial gain. While businesses may intend to celebrate diversity, misappropriation can offend communities, misrepresent cultural meaning, and create legal and reputational risks.

As global markets become more interconnected and culturally aware, brands face increasing scrutiny over marketing that draws on cultural symbols or heritage, particularly in advertising, social media, packaging, and experiential campaigns.

---

35.1 Definition

Cultural appropriation in marketing can be defined as:

“The adoption, imitation, or commercialization of cultural elements from a marginalized or distinct cultural group by a company or marketer, without consent or proper attribution, in a way that misrepresents, trivializes, or exploits that culture for marketing purposes.”

Key elements:

1. Use of cultural elements – art, fashion, symbols, rituals, language, or religious motifs.

2. Lack of consent or collaboration – not engaging with the originating community.

3. Commercial intent – use of culture primarily for profit or brand promotion.

4. Risk of misrepresentation or offense – creating negative perceptions or harm to the source culture.

---

35.2 Regulatory and Legal Context

While cultural appropriation is primarily a reputational and ethical issue, certain legal frameworks may apply:

Jurisdiction	Authority / Standard	Relevance to Marketing
United States	Trademark, copyright, Lanham Act	Cultural symbols may be protected under intellectual property; false endorsement or misrepresentation claims may apply.
United Kingdom	ASA / CAP Code, Equality Act	Marketing that offends protected groups can be challenged under advertising standards or anti-discrimination principles.
European Union	UCPD, national consumer laws	Misleading or offensive marketing can violate consumer protection or anti-discrimination regulations.
Australia	ACCC, AANA Code, Anti-Discrimination laws	Marketing that misuses cultural elements in a misleading or offensive way may breach codes or anti-discrimination laws.
Canada	Canadian Human Rights Act, Advertising Standards Canada	Marketing must avoid offensive cultural misrepresentation; intellectual property protections may apply.
Global / ICC Code	Marketing must respect cultural diversity, avoid offense, and ensure authenticity; unauthorized exploitation is discouraged.

Legal action may involve:

• Intellectual property infringement (trademarks, designs, traditional cultural expressions)

• Consumer protection claims (misleading or deceptive advertising)

• Anti-discrimination complaints

• Reputational liability with potential commercial consequences

---

35.3 Common Forms of Cultural Appropriation in Marketing

1. Fashion and Apparel

   • Using sacred or traditional attire in marketing campaigns without permission.

   • Example: Copying Indigenous patterns on products without collaboration.

2. Music and Entertainment

   • Incorporating cultural music, dances, or rituals in ads without proper credit.

3. Food and Beverages

   • Misrepresenting traditional cuisines or beverages for branding while ignoring authenticity.

4. Language and Symbols

   • Using religious, spiritual, or linguistic elements as marketing gimmicks.

5. Holidays and Rituals

   • Commercializing cultural celebrations or religious festivals in a disrespectful manner.

6. Experiential Marketing

   • Themed events, pop-ups, or promotions exploiting cultural motifs without meaningful engagement.

---

35.4 Legal Principles and Standards

1. Respect and Non-Offense

• Marketing must avoid trivializing or misrepresenting cultural heritage.

2. Consent and Collaboration

• Engage with communities to ensure authenticity, proper attribution, and shared benefit.

3. Truthfulness

• Claims about cultural origin or authenticity must be accurate and verifiable.

4. Intellectual Property Compliance

• Traditional cultural expressions may be protected by copyright, trademark, or sui generis laws.

5. Anti-Discrimination Compliance

• Avoid advertising that stigmatizes, mocks, or exploits minority groups.

6. Reasonable Consumer and Cultural Standard

• Evaluate marketing from the perspective of both consumers and members of the represented culture.

---

35.5 Industry Examples

Industry	Example	Potential Risk
Fashion	Using sacred Indigenous designs on clothing without permission	IP infringement, ASA / ACCC sanctions, public backlash
Beauty	Applying traditional cultural makeup or hairstyles for campaigns	Reputational damage, social media controversy
Food & Beverage	Marketing products as “authentic” ethnic cuisine without proper sourcing	Consumer complaints, misleading claims enforcement
Tourism	Promoting “cultural experiences” without respecting traditions	Anti-discrimination challenges, reputational harm
Music / Entertainment	Using spiritual or ritual music in ads	Copyright infringement, community backlash
Lifestyle / Home	Using sacred symbols in home décor	Ethical concerns, consumer criticism, regulatory attention

---

35.6 Digital Advertising Considerations

1. Social Media Campaigns

   • Misuse of cultural elements can rapidly go viral, magnifying reputational risk.

2. Influencer Partnerships

   • Collaborators must ensure accurate and respectful cultural representation.

3. Global Marketing

   • Different regions may have varying sensitivities; claims must respect local cultural norms.

4. User-Generated Content

   • Brands are responsible for monitoring campaigns to prevent cultural misuse by third parties.

5. Visual and Symbolic Accuracy

   • Digital creatives should accurately depict cultural elements and avoid stereotypes or trivialization.

---

35.7 Enforcement and Consequences

Jurisdiction	Agency / Mechanism	Potential Consequences
US	USPTO, FTC, community lawsuits	IP infringement suits, corrective campaigns, fines
UK	ASA, CMA, public complaints	Ad withdrawal, public apology, enforcement notices
EU	National consumer and anti-discrimination authorities	Fines, injunctions, corrective campaigns
Australia	ACCC, AANA Code, anti-discrimination complaints	Penalties, corrective campaigns, reputational damage
Global	ICC Code, industry peer sanctions	Brand boycott, social media backlash, cross-border scrutiny

Key point: Cultural appropriation often leads to reputational, regulatory, and commercial risk even if not explicitly illegal in every jurisdiction.

---

35.8 Best Practices to Avoid Cultural Appropriation in Marketing

1. Community Engagement

   • Collaborate with cultural representatives or custodians for authenticity and permission.

2. Attribution and Recognition

   • Clearly acknowledge cultural origins and contributors.

3. Cultural Sensitivity Training

   • Educate marketing teams on ethical and legal aspects of cultural representation.

4. Avoid Stereotypes

   • Do not simplify, trivialize, or commercialize cultural symbols.

5. Legal Review

   • Ensure compliance with intellectual property, anti-discrimination, and advertising regulations.

6. Transparent Marketing

   • Avoid misleading claims about authenticity, origins, or benefits.

7. Monitoring and Audit

   • Review campaigns regularly for potential cultural missteps, especially in digital media.

---

35.9 Relationship with Other Principles

Principle	Link to Cultural Appropriation in Marketing
Ethical advertising	Ensures respect for cultural diversity and integrity
Consumer protection	Prevents misleading or offensive claims
Required disclosures	Attribution, origin, and collaboration must be disclosed
Deceptive omissions	Omitting key cultural context may mislead consumers
Truthfulness	Claims about cultural authenticity must be accurate
Social impact claims	Cultural respect enhances positive social impact marketing