Health-Related Claims (Advertising & Marketing Law - concept 36)

Health-Related Claims 

Health-related claims in advertising refer to statements, suggestions, or representations made by companies about the health benefits, effects, or impacts of products or services. These claims are heavily regulated worldwide because they directly influence consumer safety, well-being, and purchasing decisions. Misleading health claims can result in consumer harm, regulatory sanctions, and reputational damage.

Health claims span food, dietary supplements, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, wellness products, fitness programs, and medical devices, making compliance both complex and essential.

---

36.1 Definition

Health-related claims can be defined as:

“Any statement, symbol, or implication in advertising or marketing that suggests a product or service can maintain, improve, or affect the physical or mental health of a consumer.”

Key elements:

1. Reference to health or well-being – physical, mental, or nutritional benefits.

2. Influence on consumer choice – claims are likely to affect purchasing decisions.

3. Requirement for substantiation – evidence must exist to support all health claims.

4. Potential for harm – misleading claims can negatively affect health or safety.

---

36.2 Regulatory Context

Health claims are among the most strictly regulated advertising claims globally. Regulatory bodies focus on truthfulness, substantiation, and consumer safety:

Jurisdiction	Authority / Standard	Regulatory Focus
United States	FDA, FTC	Claims must be truthful, not misleading, and supported by scientific evidence; includes supplements, foods, drugs, and cosmetics.
United Kingdom	ASA / CAP Code, MHRA	Health claims require substantiation, clear language, and avoidance of misleading impressions.
European Union	EFSA, UCPD, Nutrition & Health Claims Regulation (NHCR 1924/2006)	Only authorized, evidence-based health claims are allowed on foods and supplements.
Australia	TGA, ACCC	Therapeutic claims must comply with Therapeutic Goods Act, and marketing must avoid misleading or unverified claims.
Canada	Health Canada, Advertising Standards Canada	Claims must be evidence-based, not misleading, and consistent with approved product labeling.
Global / ICC Code	Health claims should always be truthful, scientifically substantiated, and not pose a risk to consumers.

---

36.3 Common Forms of Health-Related Claims

1. Nutritional Claims

   • e.g., “High in vitamin C,” “Low fat,” “Supports immune health.”

2. Therapeutic or Preventive Claims

   • e.g., “Reduces risk of heart disease,” “Prevents colds,” “Relieves joint pain.”

3. Cosmetic and Skincare Claims

   • e.g., “Reduces wrinkles,” “Improves skin elasticity,” “Prevents acne.”

4. Fitness and Wellness Claims

   • e.g., “Boosts metabolism,” “Supports weight loss,” “Enhances mental focus.”

5. Supplement and Herbal Product Claims

   • e.g., “Supports bone health,” “Promotes liver detoxification,” “Improves sleep quality.”

6. Medical Device or Treatment Claims

   • e.g., “Clinically proven to reduce blood pressure,” “FDA-approved for pain relief.”

---

36.4 Legal Principles and Standards

1. Truthfulness and Accuracy

• All health claims must reflect scientifically validated effects and cannot exaggerate benefits.

2. Substantiation Requirement

• Claims must be backed by credible clinical studies, peer-reviewed research, or regulatory approval.

3. Materiality

• Claims are actionable if they influence consumer purchasing behavior or endanger health.

4. Safety and Risk Disclosure

• Include warnings, contraindications, or side effects where relevant.

5. Reasonable Consumer Standard

• Claims must be understandable to the average consumer without misleading interpretation.

6. Regulatory Authorization

• Some claims, particularly for foods and supplements, require prior authorization from authorities (e.g., EFSA in the EU).

---

36.5 Industry Examples

Industry	Example	Compliance Risk
Food & Beverage	“Boosts immune system” without clinical evidence	FTC / EFSA enforcement, corrective advertising
Supplements	“Clinically proven to cure arthritis” without FDA approval	Legal action, fines, product withdrawal
Cosmetics	“Eliminates wrinkles in 7 days”	ASA / CMA sanctions, misleading claims enforcement
Fitness	“Burns 500 calories in 10 minutes”	Misleading claims, corrective advertising
Medical Devices	“Reduces blood pressure in 30 days” without clinical trial support	Regulatory action, litigation
Herbal Remedies	“Detoxifies the liver naturally”	Consumer complaints, enforcement notices

---

36.6 Digital Advertising Considerations

1. E-Commerce Product Listings

   • Health claims must be accurate, substantiated, and not misleading online.

2. Social Media Campaigns

   • Influencers promoting health products are liable for misleading claims, especially if compensated or incentivized.

3. Subscription & Wellness Apps

   • Claims about mental health, fitness, or dietary benefits must be evidence-based and transparent.

4. Cross-Border Marketing

   • Claims must comply with local regulations in each jurisdiction where the product is sold.

5. User-Generated Content

   • Brands must monitor endorsements to prevent misleading health claims from third parties.

---

36.7 Enforcement and Consequences

Jurisdiction	Agency / Mechanism	Potential Consequences
US	FDA, FTC	Warning letters, product recalls, fines, civil litigation
UK	ASA / MHRA	Ad withdrawal, public correction, enforcement notices
EU	EFSA / National authorities	Fines, injunctions, mandatory corrective campaigns
Australia	TGA, ACCC	Regulatory sanctions, product removal, financial penalties
Canada	Health Canada, ASC	Corrective advertising, fines, product recalls
Global	ICC Code	Industry sanctions, reputational damage, cross-border scrutiny

Key point: Misleading or unsubstantiated health claims are considered high-risk advertising violations with potential for both legal and public backlash.

---

36.8 Best Practices to Avoid Health-Related Misrepresentation

1. Substantiate Claims

   • Use clinical trials, peer-reviewed studies, or regulatory approvals to support claims.

2. Disclose Limitations

   • Include warnings, side effects, or usage instructions.

3. Avoid Absolute or Misleading Language

   • Avoid phrases like “cures,” “guaranteed,” or “proven” unless fully validated.

4. Third-Party Verification

   • Seek certification or approval from recognized regulatory bodies.

5. Audit Marketing Materials

   • Review all advertising for accuracy and compliance.

6. Team Training

   • Educate marketing, compliance, and social media teams about health claims regulations.

7. Document Evidence

   • Keep records of research, studies, and approvals for regulatory defense.

---

36.9 Relationship with Other Principles

Principle	Link to Health Claims
Truthfulness	Claims must be scientifically accurate and not misleading
Claim substantiation	Must be evidence-based and verifiable
Consumer protection	Prevents harm from misleading or false health claims
Deceptive omissions	Risks if side effects or limitations are not disclosed
Required disclosures	Warnings, limitations, and usage must be transparent
Ethical advertising	Protects consumers’ well-being and fosters trust