In our previous post, we examined what exactly a sale of goods contract is, differentiating it from other similar agreements like bailments, hire-purchase, gifts, and agency contracts. We clarified key concepts such as what counts as goods, the difference between a sale and an agreement to sell, and the legal protections involved.
Now, to fully grasp how sale contracts work, it’s essential to focus on one of their core legal elements: the transfer of property (ownership) in the goods.
This transfer of ownership is more than just handing over physical possession; it’s about who holds the full legal right to the goods—and that has major consequences for risk, remedies, and insolvency situations.
What Does “Transfer of Property” Mean?
Under the Sale of Goods Act (SGA) and modern commercial laws up to 2025, a sale contract means the seller transfers or agrees to transfer the property (legal ownership) in specific goods to the buyer, for money.
Property in law is a universal right. This means the owner’s rights are enforceable against the whole world—not just the seller or buyer.
For example, if you buy a car, your ownership is absolute and no one else can claim it without your consent. This differs from contractual rights, which bind only the contracting parties.
Sale Contract and Transfer of Property: Related but Distinct
Two key moments are distinguished in a sale:
-
The sale contract — where parties agree on the goods, price, and terms.
-
The transfer of property — the actual passing of ownership.
Sometimes these occur together, such as when goods in stock are sold and delivered immediately.
But often, especially with future or unascertained goods, ownership transfers later, when the goods are identified or delivered.
This timing affects:
-
Who legally owns the goods at a given time
-
Who bears the risk if goods are lost or damaged
-
Who can claim goods if the seller becomes insolvent
Classification of Goods: Existing, Future, Specific, and Unascertained
Existing Goods
These are goods owned or possessed by the seller at contract formation. For example, a car already in the seller’s warehouse.
Future Goods
Goods that either:
-
Do not yet exist (to be manufactured), or
-
Are owned by someone else but will be acquired by the seller later
Example: a car the seller agrees to buy from a third party and then sell to the buyer.
Important: You cannot make an immediate sale of future goods; only an agreement to sell is possible until the goods exist or are acquired.
Specific vs Unascertained Goods
Goods—whether existing or future—may be:
-
Specific goods: clearly identified and agreed upon at contract time.
Example: “My Bentley with registration ABC123.”
-
Unascertained goods: not identified or set aside at contract time.
Example: “100 televisions from our warehouse stock,” without specifying which.
Why does this distinction matter?
Ownership cannot pass for unascertained goods because you can’t transfer ownership of something unspecified.
This means:
-
Buyers of unascertained goods have only contractual rights against the seller, not ownership.
-
Ownership passes only when the goods are “ascertained” or appropriated to the contract.
Real Legal Cases Illustrating the Importance of Goods Classification
-
Re Wait (1927): Buyer contracted for 500 tons of wheat out of 1,000 tons on a ship. Seller went bankrupt before identification. Court ruled goods were unascertained, so ownership had not passed, and buyer was an unsecured creditor.
-
Goldcorp Exchange Ltd (1995): Customers purchased non-allocated gold bullion. The company failed to set aside specific bullion for buyers. At insolvency, court held ownership had not passed because goods were unascertained.
Why Does This Matter for Business?
Knowing exactly when ownership transfers helps businesses:
-
Manage risk and liability for goods lost or damaged in transit
-
Know when to record goods as assets or inventory
-
Protect themselves in insolvency situations
-
Understand when they can enforce rights over the goods
Contracts must clearly define the nature of goods sold and when they become specific or ascertained to avoid costly legal disputes.
Practical Business Example: Tech Startup and Equipment Purchase
Scenario:
InnovateX Ltd, a tech startup, needs new servers to launch a cloud service.
-
Existing and specific goods: They order specific servers that TechSupplies Ltd already owns and has in stock. Ownership and risk pass on delivery.
-
Future and unascertained goods: They agree to buy custom servers to be manufactured after the contract. This is an agreement to sell future goods. Ownership passes only when the servers are ready, identified, and appropriated to the contract.
Potential issues:
-
If InnovateX pays upfront but servers aren’t yet manufactured, and TechSupplies goes bankrupt, InnovateX risks losing money because ownership never passed.
-
If goods are damaged during transit after ownership passes, InnovateX bears the loss.
-
If the contract lacks clarity on when ownership passes, both parties face uncertainty and possible litigation.
Key Takeaways
-
A sale of goods contract involves transferring legal ownership of goods for money.
-
Ownership rights are universal and protect buyers against all third parties.
-
Goods are classified as existing or future, and specific or unascertained—this affects when ownership passes.
-
Ownership cannot pass for unascertained goods until they are identified and appropriated to the contract.
-
Clear contractual terms about goods and timing of ownership transfer help avoid risk and disputes.
By mastering these concepts, businesses can better structure deals to fit operational needs, protect their investments, and navigate risks with confidence.
Which statement correctly describes when ownership passes in a sale of goods contract?
Ownership passes immediately for specific, existing goods once they are delivered, but unascertained or future goods require identification before ownership passes
Ownership always passes as soon as a contract is signed, regardless of the nature of goods
Ownership never passes until full payment is made, regardless of delivery
Ownership passes only after goods are used or consumed by the buyer
