The role of directors and senior executives in banks is critically important. Banks operate with high leverage, fiduciary responsibility, and systemic risk exposure. Weak or unethical leadership can jeopardize not only the institution but the entire financial system.
To mitigate this risk, banking law imposes the Fit and Proper Test (FPT) for directors, senior managers, and key personnel. This test ensures that individuals leading banks are competent, honest, and financially sound.
1. What Is the Fit and Proper Test?
The Fit and Proper Test is a regulatory assessment conducted by banking authorities to evaluate whether an individual is suitable to hold a directorial or senior management role in a bank.
It focuses on three core attributes:
-
Honesty, integrity, and reputation
-
Competence and capability
-
Financial soundness
Passing this test is a mandatory requirement for appointment as a director or senior manager in licensed banking institutions.
2. Purpose of the Fit and Proper Test
The main objectives are:
a. Protect Deposit Holders and Investors
-
Ensure that bank leadership acts responsibly and ethically
-
Prevent fraud, mismanagement, or conflicts of interest
b. Safeguard Financial Stability
c. Promote Accountability
-
Directors are personally responsible for bank governance, risk management, and compliance
-
Encourages responsible decision-making and long-term stability
d. Enhance Market Confidence
-
Investors, customers, and counterparties are reassured that banks are led by qualified, ethical individuals
3. Key Criteria of the Fit and Proper Test
Regulators typically assess candidates across three major dimensions:
a. Honesty, Integrity, and Reputation
-
No history of fraud, financial crimes, or regulatory breaches
-
Good reputation in the banking and business community
-
Disclosure of any criminal records, bankruptcy, or disciplinary actions
-
Avoidance of conflicts of interest that may compromise independence
Example:
b. Competence and Capability
-
Relevant qualifications (finance, accounting, law, business administration, risk management)
-
Experience in banking, finance, or relevant industries
-
Understanding of bank operations, risk management, corporate governance, and regulatory compliance
-
Ability to make informed, strategic decisions in complex environments
Example:
-
A director of a commercial bank must understand lending, liquidity management, and capital adequacy requirements, not just marketing or sales.
c. Financial Soundness
-
Personal financial stability and prudence
-
No history of personal bankruptcy, insolvency, or poor financial management
-
Ability to manage fiduciary responsibilities without exposing the bank to risk
Example:
4. Regulatory Frameworks
a. United Kingdom
-
Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA): Fit and Proper requirements for directors and senior managers
-
Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR): Assigns personal accountability for decisions and compliance
b. European Union
c. United States
-
Federal Reserve, OCC, FDIC: Conduct suitability reviews for bank directors
-
Part of the “safety and soundness” assessment
d. Asia
-
Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS): Stringent FPT for directors and key executives
-
Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA): Ensures directors are competent, experienced, and financially sound
5. Fit and Proper Assessment Process
-
Application and Disclosure
-
Directors provide detailed personal, professional, and financial information
-
Include criminal records, civil proceedings, regulatory actions, and financial history
-
Evaluation by Regulator
-
Assessment of honesty, integrity, competence, and financial soundness
-
Verification of references, qualifications, and prior experience
-
Decision and Approval
-
Ongoing Monitoring
-
Directors are reassessed periodically
-
Significant changes in roles, financial status, or criminal history must be reported
6. Responsibilities Tied to Fit and Proper Status
Passing the FPT means the director is accountable for:
-
Strategic decision-making and risk appetite
-
Compliance with prudential and conduct regulations
-
Oversight of internal controls and corporate governance
-
Ethical and fiduciary duties to depositors, shareholders, and regulators
Failure to act responsibly can result in:
7. Real-World Example
Case: Barclays Bank Libor Scandal (2012)
-
Regulatory investigations revealed that senior executives lacked effective oversight
-
Highlighted the importance of fit and proper leadership, ethical standards, and accountability
-
Led to governance reforms and stricter FPT requirements for directors in the UK and EU
8. Challenges and Considerations
-
Global operations: Directors of multinational banks must meet FPT requirements in multiple jurisdictions
-
Evolving skillsets: Digital banking, FinTech, and cybersecurity require additional competencies
-
Ethical vs technical competence: Regulators weigh integrity and ethical behavior as heavily as professional expertise
-
Continuous monitoring: A director fit at appointment may become unfit due to changes in personal or professional circumstances
9. Conclusion
The Fit and Proper Test for bank directors is a critical pillar of banking law:
-
Ensures banks are led by competent, ethical, and financially responsible individuals
-
Protects depositors, investors, and the financial system
-
Strengthens corporate governance, transparency, and market confidence
-
Holds directors personally accountable for their decisions and oversight
For entrepreneurs, investors, regulators, and finance professionals, understanding the FPT is essential for compliance, risk management, and strategic leadership in banking.
